Can a PhD thesis consist of multiple unrelated papers/topics?

For many doctoral candidates, the prospect of composing a PhD thesis can be exhilarating. Traditionally, a PhD thesis is a comprehensive document that presents original research on a single topic, demonstrating the candidate’s mastery of their field. However, in recent years, there has been a growing trend towards adopting alternative formats, including the incorporation of multiple unrelated papers or topics into a single thesis. In this article, we delve into the merits, challenges, and considerations surrounding this approach . Can a PhD thesis consist of multiple unrelated papers/topics ?

Pros and Cons of Including Multiple Papers/Topics

One of the primary advantages of structuring a PhD thesis around multiple papers or topics is the potential for greater dissemination of research findings. By organizing the thesis in this manner, candidates can publish individual papers in peer-reviewed journals, thereby increasing the visibility and impact of their work. Additionally, integrating multiple papers allows candidates to showcase the breadth and depth of their research interests, highlighting their versatility and adaptability as scholars.

However, this approach is not without its challenges. Critics argue that a thesis composed of disparate papers may lack coherence and cohesion, making it difficult for examiners to evaluate the candidate’s overall contribution to their field. Furthermore, there is a risk that individual papers may be of varying quality or significance, raising questions about the overall rigor and scholarly merit of the thesis.

Guidelines and Requirements

The decision to include multiple papers or topics in a PhD thesis is subject to the regulations and policies of the candidate’s university or academic institution. While some institutions explicitly permit this format, others may require a more traditional thesis structure. Candidates should familiarize themselves with their university’s guidelines regarding thesis formatting and structuring to ensure compliance with academic standards.

In addition to university requirements, candidates should consider practical considerations such as formatting and structuring their thesis in a cohesive and logical manner. This may involve providing introductory and concluding chapters that contextualize the individual papers within the broader scope of the thesis and highlight the connections between them.

Examples and Case Studies

Several successful examples demonstrate the viability of integrating multiple papers or topics into a PhD thesis. For instance, interdisciplinary research projects often lend themselves to this format, allowing candidates to explore diverse aspects of a complex problem or phenomenon. Likewise, candidates conducting longitudinal studies or research in rapidly evolving fields may benefit from organizing their findings into separate papers that reflect different stages or facets of their research.

Impact on Examination and Defense

The evaluation of a PhD thesis composed of multiple papers or topics differs from that of a traditional thesis. Examiners may assess the individual papers separately, considering factors such as originality, methodology, and contribution to the field. However, they will also evaluate the thesis as a whole, examining the coherence and integration of the papers and the candidate’s overarching research agenda.

Candidates preparing to defend a thesis of this nature should be prepared to articulate the rationale behind their chosen format and demonstrate how the individual papers contribute to a cohesive and comprehensive body of research. Additionally, candidates should be prepared to address any concerns raised by examiners regarding the coherence and significance of the thesis.

Alternative Approaches

While integrating multiple papers or topics into a PhD thesis is one approach, it is not the only option available to candidates. Some may choose to publish their research findings separately, either before or after completing their thesis, while others may supplement their thesis with additional content such as literature reviews, theoretical frameworks, or methodological reflections. Ultimately, the most appropriate approach will depend on the candidate’s research goals, disciplinary norms, and institutional requirements.

Here’s a simplified version of the guidelines on the multiple-paper option for a PhD thesis:

The multiple-paper thesis option lets PhD students structure their thesis around several papers, usually three in Public Health Sciences, that the student’s thesis committee deems publishable. This option changes the format of the thesis, not its content. Papers prepared for publication have limited space, so the thesis also includes introductory chapters and a final synthesis chapter.

The thesis needs to present original research on an approved topic and make a significant contribution to the field. It should have a clear topic, an introduction outlining the research themes, and a conclusion summarizing the main findings. Even though it’s made up of several papers, the thesis should still be cohesive.

The thesis can include unpublished material, scholarly notes, and necessary appendices. It should have continuous pagination, a common table of contents, and an integrated bibliography. The hard copy should be in a standard form suitable for microfilming.

The thesis should be based on a single coherent research project, not a series of unrelated projects. The chapters and papers can cover topics like literature reviews, methodological developments, research results, policy implications, and knowledge transfer activities.

Before opting for the three-paper option, students must discuss and get approval from their thesis committee. They should consider whether peer-reviewed publications or a book is the best way to share their findings.

Students and their committees should discuss the expectations for each chapter and paper. They should agree on a tentative outline as soon as the key findings are known. The material presented at the final thesis defense must be the student’s original work, but it can be part of a collaborative project. The committee members may provide feedback on the thesis, including the papers. Authorship of the papers should be discussed between the student, supervisor, and committee


The integration of multiple papers or topics into a PhD thesis offers both opportunities and challenges for doctoral candidates. While this approach allows for greater dissemination of research findings and demonstrates the candidate’s versatility as a scholar, it also requires careful consideration of issues such as coherence, integration, and scholarly rigor. By adhering to university guidelines, organizing their thesis in a logical and cohesive manner, and effectively defending their research agenda, candidates can successfully navigate the complexities of this alternative thesis format.

Managing Anxiety: Investigating Drug Remedies